CONSTITUTIONAL COURT JUDGMENT ON POST-COMMENCEMENT FUNDER VOTING RIGHTS IN BUSINESS RESCUE

by Nov 20, 2026Business Rescue

The Mining and Natural Resources Sector has been through chaotic times, with many companies placing operations under care and maintenance, business rescue and, unfortunately, in many instances, closure and liquidation.

Several operations have avoided liquidation and closure because investors were prepared to make post-commencement funding available, knowing they had protection as post-commencement funders, including the ability to vote on the business rescue plan. Investors, in many cases, also “bought up” creditors’ claims to provide the required “voting power”.

The recent judgment of the Constitutional Court has struck a blow to these investors. In the matter of Salungano Group Ltd v Mashwai Projects (Pty) Ltd & Others: Ndalamo Coal (Pty) Ltd v Mashwai Projects (Pty) Ltd & Others [2026] ZACC 38, the Constitutional Court identified which creditors are entitled to vote on the adoption of a business rescue plan.

Arnot Opco (Pty) Ltd owns and operates the Arnot Coal Mine. Arnot Opco was placed in business rescue on 10 October 2022. Mashwayi Projects (Pty) Ltd was a creditor of Arnot Opco and had “bought up” claims from various former creditors.

Ndalamo Coal (Pty) Ltd had been voted as the successful bidder for the acquisition of Arnot Opco at a creditors’ meeting on 28 July 2023.

After this creditors meeting, allegations of voting irregularities were made, and the business rescue practitioner concluded that the threshold of 75% required in Section 152(2) of the Companies Act, No. 71 of 2008 had not been achieved. This meant that Ndalamo Coal’s bid had not been properly approved and led to the key question: are post-commencement creditors entitled to vote?

Following contradictory judgments from the High Court and the Supreme Court of Appeal, the Constitutional Court held that Chapter 6 of the Companies Act does not permit post-commencement creditors to vote in relation to the adoption of a business rescue plan.

The Constitutional Court adopted a purposive approach to the interpretation of what constitutes a “creditor” in Chapter 6 of the Companies Act and also considered Section 128 of the Companies Act, which identifies an “affected person”. The court also referred to Sections 145(2)(8), 151, and 152 of the Companies Act and concluded that voting in relation to a business rescue plan is confined to those persons who have a voting interest, being the persons who have admitted or proven claims as reflected in the business rescue plan. Section 150(2)(a)(ii) of the Companies Act requires a business rescue plan to set out a complete list of the creditors at the time when the business rescue began and their ranking.

While Section 135 of the Companies Act gives post-commencement creditors preference over other creditors, this is cold comfort. Post-commencement funders have lost their ability to vote as creditors on the adoption of a business rescue plan. Providing post-commencement financing carries risk, and the Constitutional Court has now removed one of the strongest mitigation measures against this risk.

First published in the 13th edition of LIR South Africa


If you require further information, please contact Warren Beech at warren@bv-inc.co.za.

Disclaimer: This article is provided for informational purposes only and is not intended to serve as legal advice. Readers should consult one of our legal professionals for advice tailored to their specific circumstances.